What is new york life phone number? The customer support phone number of New York Life Insurance is +1 212-576-7000, +1 800-995-7445 (Click phone number to call).What is the phone number for new york life insurance? Phone Number of New York Life Insurance is +1 212-576-7000, +1 800-995-7445 . The New York Life Insurance company is a mutual insurance service provider company. It was founded in the year 1845 as Nautilus Insurance Company.How much does new york life pay? Tell us about you and get an estimated calculation of how much you should be earning and insight into your career options. How much does New York Life in the United States pay? The average New York Life salary ranges from approximately $32,404 per year for Recruiting Assistant to $167,440 per year for Vice President.