How do i contact michigan millers mutual insurance company? (800) 888-1914. Michigan Millers Mutual Insurance Company. 2425 E. Grand River Avenue. P.O. Box 30060. Lansing, MI 48909-7560.How do i contact donegal insurance company in michigan? Michigan Insurance Company. 1700 East Beltline NE, Suite 100. P.O. Box 152120. Grand Rapids, MI 49515-2120. Phone: 888 606-6426. Make checks payable to: Donegal Insurance Group.Where do i send my michigan insurance company checks? Michigan Insurance Company. 1700 East Beltline NE, Suite 100. P.O. Box 152120. Grand Rapids, MI 49515-2120. Phone: 888-606-6426. Make checks payable to:How do i contact liberty mutual auto insurance? Liberty Mutual - Contact Us. Phone: 1-800-426-9898 (24/7) Additional charges apply if your policy does not include the towing and labor coverage.