What is the telephone number for customer service? 1-800-566-0065, Customers can also use this number to reach to the customer service representatives of the company. 1-800-238-0271 is the fax number of the company, which can be used to send the orders.Who owns fay servicing? Fay Servicing LLC Flag Star Bank King Alligator who is the creator and founder of Fay Servicing Ed Fay. He is flank by his under boos Andy Liang, CEO, Kimberly Bingham President, and Ryan Finnigan VP. THE ILLEGAL FORECLOSURE TACTICS EMPLOYED BY FAY SERVICING Springfield IL Show customers why they should trust your business over your competitors...What is fay servicing llc? Fay Servicing, LLC operates as a specialty mortgage debt management company. It provides servicing solutions for performing and non-performing mortgages. The company was founded in 2008 and is based in Springfield, Illinois. Fay Servicing, LLC operates as a subsidiary of Fay Financial, LLC.