How do i contact fanatics customer service? Fanatics Customer Service Phone Number (855) 346-8602, Email, Address. Sport Equipment and Accessories.What is fanatics return policy? Fanatics offers a wide return window—the company allows you to return your product up to 365 days from the shipping date! Make sure the item is in good condition and with original tags before you pack it up and seal the box. Final sale items and Fanatics Outlet products are non-returnable.Is fanatics a good website to buy from? Overview Fanatics has a consumer rating of 2.19 stars from 2,252 reviews indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Consumers complaining about Fanatics most frequently mention customer service, day shipping and business days problems. Fanatics ranks 1st among Jersey sites.How long does fanatics take to respond to customer services? [email protected]. We endeavour to respond to all emails within 24 hours.